COBALT successfully represented Petra Medical OÜ, a supplier of medical devices, surgical instruments and orthopaedic aids, in a public procurement dispute concerning the purchase of surgical equipment by the Tartu University Hospital Foundation.
The review proceedings before the Public Procurement Review Committee reaffirmed the principle that excessive formalism is not permitted in public procurement. This means that any ambiguity in the information provided in a tender must not automatically lead to a negative decision against the tenderer (in this case, the decision not to qualify the tenderer). The contracting authority has a statutory right and obligation to consider giving the tenderer the opportunity to submit or supplement information or documents where deficiencies can be rectified. The contracting authority may not exercise this discretion arbitrarily. The opportunity to rectify deficiencies must be given where the required documents or information have not been submitted or are unclear or insufficient, or where it is evident that the tenderer has made a human error when preparing the documents.
In summary, the Review Committee annulled the contracting authority’s decisions, as the contracting authority had, without justification, failed to give the tenderer the opportunity to rectify the deficiencies. The Review Committee also emphasised that the lawfulness of a contracting authority’s decision is assessed on the basis of the reasons the contracting authority relied on when making it. Reasons given later, which the decision was not based on, cannot be taken into account when assessing the lawfulness of the decision.
The client was represented by Managing Associate Kaidi Reiljan-Sihvart. The team also included Associate Marleen Sarap.